rodrigomorr

Review

This is the definition of safe but also boring.

Castley by Parfums de MarlyParfums de MarlyCastley3.864 ratings
2/5
Longevity4/5
4 / 5
Projection4/5
4 / 5
Sillage2/5
2 / 5
Value1/5
1 / 5
Bottle4/5
4 / 5
  • After several wears
  • Tested at home
  • On skin

This opens similar to Imagination and ends up almost the same as YSL Y EdP.

The backbone of this is masculine cleanliness, with a touch more formality than Imagination and a tiny bit more interesting than YSL Y. It hits your nose in a spicy way because it is VERY PEPPERY, but it quickly goes away and resembles clean laundry.

This paints a picture of that one office boss that's always very well put, sharp dressed and has a very neutral attitude, you can't quite pinpoint his sexuality but there's rumours that he's gay tho. And that's a huge compliment to this BUT this perfume, even tho PdM has a VERY HIGH quality, is just not interesting at all for me.

My nose mostly perceives some ambiguous citrus but also a lot of pepper in the opening which then slowly transforms into a clean laundry type of scent, has a slight muskyness and also an apple-y slightly sweet ambrocenidic dry-down that is what resembles YSL Y so much.

Occasions is just your regular day to day, office, work, running errands kind of thing, nothing worth paying 350 dlls for IMO.

I'd personally give this a 3/10 only valuable thing is the fact that it is NOT unpleasant, but it ends up smelling exactly the same as Armaf's Odyssey Mega in the dry-down, which is a huge bummer cus you can get that one for like 20 bucks at Jomashop. I also got a review of that one in my profile if you're interested 🙌

So to sum it all up, it's not bad, but it's nothing new, also nothing makes it worth the price IMO, you can get this for a much cheaper, wasn't expecting much since PdM mostly makes high quality dupes and not really anything original.

The declared notes are:

Top: Bergamot, Ginger, Black Pepper

Heart: Petitgrain, Timut Pepper, Neroli.

Base: Akigalawood, Labdanum, Benzoin.

Open in app

From the story

Comments9

  1. FoxHound215@foxhound215

    · Edited

    Castley is a good one! It's definitely similar to Imagination but not quite. I think Castley is the cross between Imagination and Sedley. And btw, I thought you were reviewing that drink!

    On the story
    1. rodrigomorr

      I got a sample of castley, been using it for 3 days straight, I just didn't take a pic of it. Yeah Castley is good, it's just not outstanding to me and for that price, I expect something outstanding.

      On the story
    2. FoxHound215@foxhound215

      Replying to @rodrigomorr

      Yes it's definitely not outstanding. It's generic and there's nothing wrong with it- it's just not incredible. I think the same regarding Percival, Sedley and many other PDM. I used to own multiple PdMs but I sold them all and only kept the one I truly enjoy- Greenley.

      On the story
  2. doelly

    That drink looks delicious! Great review too. I am also not generally a fan of PDM. Though I do love a few of their perfumes.

    On the story
    1. rodrigomorr

      Thanks, I do value quite highly that PdM has a great quality, I love Haltane for example,

      On the story
    2. rodrigomorr

      Replying to @rodrigomorr

      Oh and that drink is a guava + pineapple lemonade that I made

      On the story
    3. doelly

      Replying to @rodrigomorr

      Sounds amazing! And yes I can't deny that they do make good quality perfumes!

      On the story
  3. Curlyhen@curlyhen

    3/10… oouufff!

    On the story
    1. rodrigomorr

      It's just not for me 😬

      On the story

Join the conversation in WhatScent

Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.