Megan Melancholy@meganmelancholy
· Edited
Heretic ParfumDirty Peach3.99 ratingsYesterday I wore this out and about and smelled lovely out in open air. Today I put it on at home and immediately started smelling something "off". I then checked reviews and see some people get a cat pee smell, I would say it's more a dirty nasty armpit or something but uh yeah it's definitely there 😅
Wore it on August 14, 2026
MoMarie@momarie
Yeah, I got urine from this one 🫤 I (mostly) love Heretic, but this was a miss. Not the first time I’ve had peach go weird on me in a fragrance though, I think it must be a tricky note to execute well.
Megan Melancholy@meganmelancholy
What's your favorite from heretic? I loooove Pistil Whip but haven't tried any but these two. I read it's the cassis/black currant note that does goes that way, guess I'll be avoiding that now lol. I was already hesitant because of the ylang ylang which has gone ick on me before. I wear peach a lot and was excited for this one based on first smell but maybe the lake over whelmed that last night 😅
MoMarie@momarie
Replying to @meganmelancholy
I haven’t tried Pistil Whip yet but have heard great things! I own Black Salt, Dirty Hinoki, and Fourteen Carrots, and love them all. If I were to add another from Heretic to my collection right now it would probably be either Scandalwood or Coeur Noir. I also have The Haunted Tea Cosy room spray and loooove it (that might actually be my favorite out of everything I’ve sampled from them!).
Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.
