OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

Review

Through the Ishtar Gate

Babylon by Penhaligon'sPenhaligon'sBabylon4.172 ratings
4/5
Longevity4/5
4 / 5
Projection3/5
3 / 5
Sillage3/5
3 / 5
Value3/5
3 / 5
Bottle4/5
4 / 5

Named after a Mesopotamian metropolis that blossomed into an empire, I expected Babylon to smell truly imperial - lush terraces of date-palm greenery, woody spices curling from household hearths, and sweet ceremonial incense suffusing the air with wonder. It takes me halfway there.

As we pass through the Ishtar Gate, a deep-brown, non-sweet, nutmeg-infused vanilla greets us, reflecting the opulence of the city beyond. Venturing down the Processional Way, the desert sun bakes the air sweeter, while a light breeze carries hints of saffron-flecked pastries from the bakery, and cedar beams from the carpenter's yard, their joints sealed with smoky, leathery tar. Approaching the end of the avenue, we pass the Temple of Marduk, where priests swing bundles of sandalwood embers and chant hymns to their gods.

I take great pleasure in weaving imaginative tales around fragrances, especially those with a historical inspiration, yet at its core, Babylon is simply a rich, woody vanilla. It feels rounded, full-bodied, and only mildly sweet, as though pure vanilla extract were brushed onto creamy woods and left to cure beneath the Persian sun.

It's a beautiful scent, but it reminds me of many others and feels a little too one-dimensional to really wow me.

Open in app

Comments14

  1. Jess.@jess.scents

    Thank you for the evocative review 🙂

    1. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      You're very welcome. Slowly making my way through the 100s of reviews I have saved on my phone 😄

  2. Incense_Cat@incensecat

    I recently got some of this one and had the same feeling. It's nice, but very close to many others I have in that realm, and ultimately nothing stands out enough to make me reach for it over those.

    1. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      Yeah, my thoughts exactly. I'd sooner reach for Babycat or Eau Duelle if I wanted something similar, but really, Angélique Noire & Ani are the only vanillas I need.

  3. Global Warning@emmanuel

    They say they watered it down :(

    1. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      · Edited

      That wouldn't surprise me. Other than Halfeti, which certainly sticks around, I'm yet to try a Penhaligon's that has true, all-day presence. I find most of them open quite boldly, but after a couple of hours go very quiet. I got a good 8-10 hours from Babylon, which is better than most, but had to search for it after the 3-hour mark.

    2. Global Warning@emmanuel

      Replying to @oliveeyes94

      That’s not bad at all tbh

    3. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      · Edited

      Replying to @emmanuel

      I found Babylon, Halfeti and Cairo to perform pretty well. Petra did ok too. The ones I've tried from The Portraits/Potions Collections faded much more quickly.

Join the conversation in WhatScent

Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.