Ylang Ylang Custard@ylang_ylang_custard
· Edited
Heretic ParfumRhubarb Thief4.18 ratingsLeans a little medicinal at first spritz. The heart notes are pleasant. As a rhubarb fan, I expected to love this, but I find myself surprisingly underwhelmed. Have to try this again on a different day, I guess.
Wore it on August 5, 2026
Vibes
Ducki@happyducki
From the reviews I see a lot of ppl saying they get way more grapefruit than rhubarb which is disappointing:( I want to like Heretic so bad bc the bottles and vibes are aesthetically appealing lol
Ylang Ylang Custard@ylang_ylang_custard
Yeah, I get the grapefruit thing! I’m finding that Heretic is hit or miss. For me, they’re either fabulous or meh with little in between. All 3 frags in the Nocturnal line were wonderful to my nose! The Rhubarb Thief collection has been a disappointment with the exception of Fourteen Carrots.
Shannon
After days of gloom, the sun finally made an appearance! In celebration of this I chose to wear Rhubarb Thief ❤️ It’s green, fresh, sweet, slightly floral. It's definitely got a grapefruit or a
GhostPie
I know grapefruit is similar to rhubarb in smell, but I feel like this fragrance should have been called “Dirty Grapefruit” instead. That’s much more fitting. It’s extremely sweet and bright upon
Kitkat
In love with Rhubarb Thief, from the opening to the dry down. Still looking for the perfect layering partner.
Eirik
Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.
