Kaide@kaide

· Edited

Review

Scent Review: Guerlain Shalimar EdP

Shalimar Eau de Parfum by GuerlainGuerlainShalimar Eau de Parfum4.0165 ratings
3/5
Longevity4/5
4 / 5
Projection4/5
4 / 5
Value2/5
2 / 5
Bottle5/5
5 / 5
  • Full wear
  • Tested at home
  • On skin

Guerlain Shalimar EdP

This is a scent that my sister has been looking for but the original one. When my sister was just starting out in the workforce my Mom had given her a little bottle and my sister ADORED it! So she bought this one hoping it would be the same. Sadly it was not.

She let me try it. It is not for me. I love my florals, fruity & fresh scents but I am willing to try a scent unless it smells like a heavily sweet gourmand.

This was not good on me. At all. It is very smoky and incense-y on me. It is what you would expect an old church to smell like. Not the modern churches with all the white interiors but rather an older church with all the wood and stained glass windows - think St. Patrick's in NYC.

I could even see someone who has a library at home that smokes cigars as they sit in their club chairs enjoying a brandy after dinner. That is another image that this scent evokes in my mind.

Considering all the notes that are in this fragrance, for me, this is pretty linear. It stays smoky the whole time and I don't get any of the other notes. Based on my experience, this is a heavy scent ideal for the colder months. I can also see this being cloying and suffocating. Not something you can overspray.

While this is categorized as a women's fragrance I could definitely see it working for both men and women especially with how it works with my pH. In my opinion, this is NOT a safe blind buy at all.

If you enjoy heavy, smoky fragrances that have staying power then you may enjoy this one.

Fragrance Family: Amber Oriental Fragrance Notes: Top: Citruses, Bergamot, Lemon, Cedar and Mandarin Orange Middle: Iris, Patchouli, Vetiver, Jasmine and Rose Base: Incense, Vanilla, Leather, Opoponax, Civet, Sandalwood, Tonka Bean and Musk.

#ScentReview #Kaide

Open in app

From the story

Comments12

  1. GreenOlive@greenolive

    I always love to see peoples reactions to Shalimar! I don't love or hate, I can understand why it is so polarizing. I love to hear people's take on it.

    1. Kaide@kaide

      Given time it would grow on me but I have other scents I would rather wear. I am entertained as well to see folks takes on fragrances!

  2. Funky Waters@madbrain

    Wore this yesterday, and as a man, I 💯 agree. It was divine on me. I'd still love this on a woman, but yes, it's masculine.

    1. Kaide@kaide

      Definitely a Fall or Winter scent! I know it would grow on me but I have other scents I enjoy more.

  3. GreenOlive@greenolive

    I read about the history of Shalimar and it really gave me a better understanding of the fragrance. It was meant to be a rebellious type of fragrance for women that challenged gender identity in a time where women were relegated to voiceless roles in society. It was definitely used as a push back to patriarchal ideas of the early 20th century.

  4. fil@filledoux

    I adore this scent. I got mine from a fellow fraghead and i love love love how it just gets complex on me. I love old libraries, the scent of old churches, the candlewax and incense of it all.

    1. Kaide@kaide

      Then this is right in your wheelhouse!! Have you tried any of the BBW Oud scents? I have reviews of those coming!

  5. YadaYadaYada89@yadayadayada89

    My favorite Guerlain is Habit Rouge Spirit. It has a lot of similarities to Shalimar.

    On the story
    1. Kaide@kaide

      I will have to look into that one!

      On the story
  6. Fragrans Veritas@fragransveritas

    I have the Eau de Cologne and quite like it. Should I try this one?

    On the story
    1. Kaide@kaide

      I did a review earlier which may help you decide! 😁

      On the story
  7. cmewiththemhandz@guerlinaughty

    Shalimar is my bedtime fragrance!

    On the story

Join the conversation in WhatScent

Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.