Kurky, but Make It Less Soapy

I realized today that these two are almost identical to my nose. I can tell them apart, definitely, but I actually prefer Mad Potion to Kurky (when I actually used to think it was the other way around).

I used to BARELY be able to detect MP, while K had always been a clean, fruity, lightly musky scent that I appreciated for its light, musky, hazy fruitiness—now though, my nose finds it flatter (and *certainly* less sweet) than MP.

I think K has got MP beat on complexity, but, where MP has a more potent vanilla lean, K has a slightly tart, citric lean that reminds me of dish soap.

If the choice is between smelling like muted dish soap or a musky vanilla snack, I know which I prefer (it's always snack. I pay to smell like snackies thank you).