cmewiththemhandz@guerlinaughty

Review

A tale of two smellies

Musc Ravageur by Frederic MalleFrederic MalleMusc Ravageur4.1167 ratings
4/5
Longevity5/5
5 / 5
Projection5/5
5 / 5
Sillage4/5
4 / 5
Value1/5
1 / 5
Bottle1/5
1 / 5
  • After several wears
  • Tested at home
  • On skin

When I first smelled this in 2010 i didn’t react much to it compared to Une Rose and Bois d’Orage (French Lover). Noir Epices was even more tempting so I got a travel trio of those because I was 17 and paid $8/hr. Malle and niche was out of reach— commercial was not really ok, so I usually was at the estate sales, vintage shops, and ESPECIALLY the weird perfume stores that used to exist but now have been basterdized. Those stores sold vintage Guerlain, Caron, and others for below market price by 20% or more of the ORIGINAL STICKER PRICE.

I pine for those jubilant days of an excess of choices unexplored and unknown.

2008: Matte Cap First Formula (mentally unwell people like me do believe there was a 2003 and 2005 change but like shut up! This is a weird dusty cinnamon thing. I don’t understand it but I like it. Not quite of a ravaging musk like Muscs Koublai Kahn by Serge Lutens, instead a dry spicy oriental. Not much to say about this to be frank. But I’m not frank, I’m @guerlinaughty. Close to Opium but billed as a musk fragrance, but they only got halfway there

2013: 2nd formula pre-Lauder (2/3/4th formulation if you drink the clozapine kool aid). This is my preferred bottle of the two. I have about 50mL of both which is cool so I just layer them. This is a nice dirty musk— NOT animalic musk, but dirty dirty synthetic musks that I have played with before like Costausol and Givescone. There are white musks but not any “laundry musks” so not B&B Linen B.S. this is a fatty prime rib of a fragrance and I’ve gotten a LOT of compliments from strangers

Top 75 of time

Open in app

From the story

Comments12

  1. cmewiththemhandz@guerlinaughty

    @oliveeyes94 here ya go!

    1. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      A fatty prime rib of a fragrance...sounds like a bit of me. How does that 2013 bottle compare to the post-Lauder formulation?

    2. cmewiththemhandz@guerlinaughty

      Replying to @oliveeyes94

      I’m gonna be blunt— they smell nothing alike. After maintaining my collection I went to the Malle store in LA and was extremely disappointed

    3. OliveEyes@oliveeyes94

      Replying to @guerlinaughty

      Well that's a bummer, but if anyone knows how to skim the cream, it's Estee Lauder. My little decant indeed feels like it's missing a whole lot of oomph.

  2. Curlyhen@curlyhen

    I think Musc Ravageur is a stunning scent. Clean but old money dirty sexy. I’m trying to convince the other half to wear it.

    1. cmewiththemhandz@guerlinaughty

      Get that partner some some stinky juice stat

    2. JMonique@chi2thebay

      I can’t keep my hands off my other half when he wears Musc Ravageur

    3. Curlyhen@curlyhen

      Replying to @chi2thebay

      This is what I’ve told him lol.. the samples sitting waiting for him

Join the conversation in WhatScent

Reply, react, save the scents you love and log your own wears. Your fragrance journal and community in one app.